Buffalo Pizza & Island Food Menu (Update 2026)

Step into Buffalo Pizza & Island Food at 1769 Main St, Buffalo, NY, and dive into a vibrant menu that celebrates both Jamaican authenticity and classic Buffalo favorites. Experience the bold spices of jerk chicken and curry goat, paired with traditional rice & peas, plantains, and colorful vegetables. Slice into specialty pizzas like jerk chicken or oxtail, or bite into crispy wings bursting with flavor. The menu blends comfort with island flair, catering to locals and tourists alike. Whether you're craving a hearty dinner or a quick lunch, every dish promises authentic taste and quality.

Enjoy our friendly atmosphere and quick service, whether dining in, taking away, or having it delivered. Buffalo's flavor scene just got tastier—join us today and discover your new favorite meal.

Jamaican Cuisine
Jamaican Specialty Pizza & Subs
Dinners
Buffalo Style Pizza
Wings & Things
Pizza & Wing Combo
Subs
Combos
Sides
Desserts
Beverages
Buffalo Pizza & Island Food Menu image 1
Buffalo Pizza & Island Food Menu image 2
Buffalo Pizza & Island Food Menu image 3
Buffalo Pizza & Island Food Menu image 4
Buffalo Pizza & Island Food

Interior, Food, and Ambiance at Buffalo Pizza & Island Food

The casual, trendy decor creates an inviting vibe at Buffalo Pizza & Island Food. The space is well-maintained, wheelchair accessible, and perfect for solo dining or groups. The aroma of Jamaica’s spices fills the air, complementing the lively yet relaxed atmosphere. Whether you sit inside for a quick bite or opt for takeaway, the friendly staff ensures a memorable experience. Bright, friendly service polishes the authentic feel, making every visit welcoming. Enjoy your meal amid vibrant decor that pays tribute to Jamaica’s vibrant culture. It’s the perfect spot when craving comfort food with a tropical twist, whether for lunch or dinner. The ambiance reflects a community love for bold, flavorful eating, connecting Buffalo to the Caribbean soul through every bite.

Buffalo Pizza & Island Food

About Buffalo Pizza & Island Food - Food & Specialties

At Buffalo Pizza & Island Food, I savor a mix of Jamaican dishes and Buffalo classics that hit all the right notes. Their jerk chicken packs a smoky punch, while the curry goat melts off the bone, showcasing authentic Jamaican cooking. The oxtails come tender and flavorful, served with rice & peas and seasoned vegetables, true to Jamaican tradition. Vegetarian options appeal, like rice and beans, cabbage, and veggie patties. The specialty pizzas, including jerk chicken and oxtail varieties, highlight the fusion of island flavors with New York-style crust. Each dish reflects a commitment to authentic, bold flavors served at affordable prices between $15 and $30. This spot delivers not just food but a cultural experience, bringing the joy of Caribbean cuisine to Buffalo’s diverse food scene.

Buffalo Pizza & Island Food

At Buffalo Pizza & Island Food, our commitment centers on authenticity, quality, and community. We specialize in Jamaican culinary classics like oxtails, curry chicken, and jerk chicken, crafted with traditional spices and cooking methods. Our vision is to be Buffalo's premier Caribbean eatery, connecting diverse communities through bold flavors and welcoming service. We prioritize customer satisfaction, offering customizable dishes to meet dietary preferences—vegetarian options included. Our goal is to create an atmosphere where every guest feels at home, enjoying fresh, flavorful foods at affordable prices.

We continually update our menu with innovative twists on traditional dishes, aiming to preserve the essence of Jamaican culture while embracing Buffalo's vibrant food scene. Our staff's dedication ensures your experience is memorable, making us a cornerstone of Buffalo’s diverse culinary landscape.